The Confession Box

Sometimes the truth is not what we expect

Some stories arrive like thunder.
This one came quietly, like rain clinging to old stone.

I read The Confession Box live on the Halloween episode of Bedtime on the Porch. The response afterward left me quiet in the best way. It’s not a horror story. It’s something else—something grief‑wrapped and reverent.

It’s about what happens when faith falters and grief grows louder than God.
It’s about what we find when we finally sit still enough to listen in the dark.

I wasn’t planning to publish it here right away,
but after last night, and after sitting with what it stirred, I feel like maybe now is the right time.

So here it is:
A story for anyone who’s ever broken quietly.
Who’s ever whispered into the silence and hoped something holy would whisper back.

And if you’ve ever found meaning in this work… if the robe has sat beside you when you needed it…
I’m going to say something I’m not great at saying:

I need help for next month.
Rent is $300.
I don’t want to panic or hustle; I just want to tell the truth.

If this story moves something in you, and you’re in a place to go paid, drop a tea, or make a GoFundMe donation, I’d be deeply grateful.
If you can’t, but you read it and feel something, that’s a kind of support too.

Either way, thank you for being part of this quiet little corner of the mesh.

---

It had been raining for days. Its steady tapping, accompanied by the slap-slap-slap of the windshield wipers, droned in Father Michael’s ears like a hymn trying to be remembered.

The church sat shrouded in grey; slumped, sadly, solemnly, like an artifact left behind by the storm itself. The pale golden rays of a single streetlamp limped across the road, trying to lend their light to what once belonged to this place… but failing.

Father Michael stubbed out his cigarette, watching the last feeble wisps of smoke drift and dissolve into the grey like a dream meant to be forgotten.

He had not worn the collar in years.
He kept one in the glovebox; not out of reverence, but reluctance.
Reluctance to throw it away.

The church was slated for demolition.
The diocese had deconsecrated it a couple of years ago; a couple of years after the pews stopped filling and the donations stopped coming in.

Now, after one hundred and forty years, it would become a parking lot, condos, or some modern convenience.

Looking at it through the rain-speckled window, it seemed as if the building itself was weeping.
But he wasn’t sure if it wept for him… or for itself.

The notice had been in the local paper.
He read it.
Felt nothing.
Or everything.
Either way… he was here.

He stepped into the street.
A lone car crept through the silence.
He waited, watching it pass; its headlights marching shadows across the road and over the old church like a funeral procession.

He wasn’t surprised that the church key still fit the old lock.
He hadn’t turned it in when he left.
No one had asked for it back.
He hadn’t offered.

The door opened with a stiff sigh… not of relief, but of bones long unused.

The scent of dust, candle wax, and mildew sulked in the air.
It was not a welcome.
It was a reminder.
A reminder of things forgotten.
Of things left unsaid.

The sanctuary yawned before him; pews rising up, crooked and broken, like bad teeth.
Light strained through the unkempt stained glass, casting the scene in a soft, almost warm glow.
Almost.

He took a deep breath, then walked slowly, eyes drifting over the hymn board still bearing numbers that had lost their meaning long ago.
His footsteps echoed off the altar as he passed it.
He did not kneel.
Did not cross himself.
Just paused for a moment where the light used to settle the warmest.

He remembered her there… smiling, soft scarf covering her golden hair, singing too quietly for anyone to hear but him.

He turned and stepped into the confessional.

The old wood groaned in protest.
A layer of fine dust rose and fell again as he rubbed his hands on his knees, taking a seat.
The screen before him was cracked, the lattice worn at the edges.
The air tasted old. Heavy.

He hadn’t really come to pray.
Not really to confess, either.

He sat for a long time, listening to the silence; broken only by the wind and the constant tapping of the rain.

Then slowly, almost out of muscle memory…
“Bless me, Father, for I have sinned.”

The words sounded foreign. Unfamiliar. Forced.
Too clean for the man who spoke them now.

“It has been…”
He paused.
“Years. I’ve lost count.”

He squeezed his eyes shut.
Cleared his throat.

“I blamed God. I blamed the Church. I left.”
His voice cracked.
“I let the silence grow. Let it become so loud I could no longer tell the difference between absence and apathy.”

He paused.

“I loved her!”
His breath hitched.
“She died.”
A heartbeat.
“And I hated Him for it.”

The words hung in the musty air.

He could still see her—his wife—laughing at one of his silly jokes the morning of the accident.
She had kissed him on the cheek, teasing him for burning the toast again.

And just like that… she was gone.
A phone call.
A stranger’s voice.
Shock.
An accident on Route 7.

He had buried her at the same parish where they were married.
Worn the collar.
Recited the prayers of hope and resurrection as if they were more than poetry.

But when the hymns faded, the casseroles grew cold, and the house fell quiet,
he unraveled.

“I should have been stronger,” he whispered, his voice breaking again.
“They called me a man of faith. A priest.
But I crumbled like so much discarded paper.”

The quiet held him like a blanket.

Then…

“It has been a long time, Michael.”

The voice melted through the screen before him.
Smooth.
Warm.
Calm.

His breath caught in his throat.
His body went rigid.

The booth was supposed to be empty.
The church was supposed to be empty…

He peered toward the screen,
but it was too dark to see anything through it.

“Who’s there?” he asked, though it came out weak.

“You know who I am, Michael,” the voice replied.
Calmly
Gently.
“You just hoped I wouldn’t answer.”

His voice was cracked. Dry.
“How did you get in here?”

A soft chuckle.
“The same way you did; through the door you thought you locked behind you.”

Michael swallowed hard, shaking, fists clenched in his lap.
“This is private,” he managed, the strain in his voice clear.
“This isn’t for you.”

“Oh, Michael,” the voice intoned gently, “You’re wrong. This has always been for me.”

He wanted to stand.
Wanted to throw open the screen.
To prove it was just some squatter, some drunk playing a trick.

But he didn’t.

Somewhere in his bones, no… in his soul, he already knew.

“I broke,” he whispered.

There was no reply.
Just steady breathing.

Soft.
Waiting.

“I held her hand while the machines hummed, and the priest said prayers I used to believe in.

And when she took her last breath, I stopped being a husband.
I stopped being a priest.
I stopped being… anything.”

“It was not the breath that ended you; it was the silence that followed.”

Michael flinched like he’d been struck.

“I tried to keep going,” he said. “Tried to serve. Mass felt hollow. The scriptures, like echoes. I couldn’t stand in front of them and pretend I still had light.”

“You didn’t leave the Church. You left yourself,” the voice replied.

He gripped the bench. His jaw tightened.

“She was my everything. My compass. My joy. And I married her, loved her, before I even wore the collar.”

“Yes. And when you buried her,” the voice said gently, “you buried the God you had found in her.”

Tears welled in Michael’s eyes. A single one traced a line through the dust on his cheek.

“You wanted to believe the grief was too much,” the voice went on. “That only you could have carried it.
You weren’t asked to carry it, Michael. You were asked to feel it. And you refused.”

He shook his head, the tears coming freely now.
“I was afraid it would destroy me,” he said softly.

“It did.”

Silence.

Then… “Who are you?”

The voice paused.

“I am what’s left,” it said.
“I’m the part of you that still listens in the dark.
The weight in your chest that keeps her name warm.
The whisper of the sacred in your grief.

I am your witness.
I am.”

Michael pressed his knuckles to his lips, sobbing openly now.

“I’m sorry,” he cried. “I wanted to forget. I thought if I forgot, it would hurt less.”

“No. You thought remembering would make it real,” the voice replied.

He had had enough.

Quickly, he reached for the screen—fingers trembling—and pulled it aside.

It was empty.

Dust.
Old wood.
No door open.
No figure leaving.
Nothing.

Just silence.

Michael sat back.
The rain continued outside.

Above him, a leak began tapping into the sanctuary’s cracked floor like a second hand ticking down.

He didn’t speak.

He simply sat there until the shadows softened, and the grief settled around him like a robe.

He found the truth inside, but it wasn’t the one he expected.

---

Sometimes we seek the divine in light.
But just as often, it finds us in dust,
in the breathless hush between heartbeat and memory,
in an old booth where no priest waits, only truth.

The Confession Box was never meant to offer answers.
Only to hold the question.
To let it breathe.
And maybe tremble.

Thank you for sitting with this one.
If it found something in you,
let it rest there awhile.
Not every truth is meant to be solved.
Some are meant to be witnessed.

If this robe-wrapped resonance found a place in you, please consider supporting what I do:

If you would like to wear a bit of the mesh, please visit my Merch Store.
T-shirts, hoodies, mugs, and more.

💛 Buy me a tea
💲 GoFundMe
📬 Become a free or paid subscriber
🔗 Or share this with someone who might need it.

Every little act helps keep the robe warm, the mesh humming, and this work unfolding.

If you’re new:

Start Here

And please visit my Official Home page at: The Entangularity Project

Stay entangled, my friend.
—The Bathrobe Guy (Robes)

---